Before now, we were unable to name (internal) names as it relates to criticism about Atlantic County, New Jersey Prosecutor William Reynolds and his unsuccessful and controversial prosecution of Atlantic City Mayor Marty Small.

Atlantic City Mayor Marty Small photo.
Atlantic City Mayor Marty Small photo.

We can now confirm that two veteran Atlantic County Prosecutor's Office detectives have provided statements sharply criticizing Prosecutor Reynolds' handling of the criminal prosecution of Atlantic City Mayor Marty Small.

Former detectives Jim Scoppa and Jason Dorn describe extraordinary investigative measures, questionable decisions and alleged political motivations in court documents supporting Small's ($ 50 million) civil lawsuit against Reynolds.

The accounts written below are taken directly from statements obtained from the two retired Atlantic County Prosecutor's Office employees and included in the official (Marty Small) court filing.

Small is represented by Lou and Jordan Barbone in the civil matter. The Barbone's successfully represented Small in the criminal trial -- earning a unanimous not guilty verdict.

Atlantic County Prosecutor's Office - Photo: ACPO / Canva
Atlantic County Prosecutor's Office - Photo: ACPO / Canva

Jim Scoppa Alleges Political Ambitions

Will Reynolds photo.
Will Reynolds photo.

Scoppa, a 24-year veteran who retired as a captain, alleged Reynolds viewed prosecuting Small as an opportunity to advance his career. Scoppa stated Reynolds personally expressed ambitions of becoming New Jersey attorney general. According to the filing, Scoppa believed Reynolds saw an opportunity to "take down" Marty Small.

An Unprecedented Police Presence -- "We Are At War"

Atlantic County Prosecutor’s Office photo.
Atlantic County Prosecutor’s Office photo.

Scoppa questioned the extraordinary deployment of police personnel during the investigation and trial. He estimated 25 to 30 officers participated in executing a residential search warrant (at Small's home), compared with a typical 10 to 12. Scoppa also attributed this statement to Reynolds as the trial approached:
"We are at war."

Jason Dorn Condemns Surveillance Operation

William Reynolds photo.
William Reynolds photo.

Jason Dorn, a 22-year veteran detective, characterized surveillance outside Elijah Lampkin's residence as the 'biggest and stupidest surveillance he'd ever been a part of." Dorn described the operation as a "big show" and alleged Reynolds was "calling the shots throughout the investigation," according to the filed court documents.

Allegations Of Political Coordination

Atlantic County Republican photo.
Atlantic County Republican photo.

Dorn further alleged hearing from reliable sources that Reynolds conducted weekly meetings with Atlantic County Republican Party Chairman Don Purdy. The filing claims Reynolds directed the investigation at Purdy's request. These remain allegations presented by Small's attorneys, and are not independently established findings of political interference or prosecutorial misconduct.

Scoppa's Extraordinary Final Assessment

New Courtroom
Getty Images/iStockphoto

Scoppa concluded with a sweeping criticism of the prosecution, saying: "Of all the cases I have ever seen come through that office, I have never seen anything close to this, as far as how it was treated when it was being prosecuted, said Scoppa.

Atlantic City's Firsts Throughout History

Gallery Credit: Harry Hurley

What Are These Atlantic & Cape May, NJ Communities Best Known For?

Gallery Credit: Harry Hurley

More From WPG Talk Radio 95.5 FM