Our Favorite Chicken Pot Pies In The Atlantic City, N.J. Area

Our team of family foodies, listeners and readers have gone in search of the best chicken pot pies in the Atlantic City, New Jersey area.

We have found some wonderful examples.

THE HISTORIC SMITHVILLE INN - SMITHVILLE, NEW JERSEY

The Coppola Family owns and manages an amazing restaurant and community.

The Historic Smithville Inn has been open since 1787, two years before George Washington became the first President of The United States.

Now that’s history!

The Smithville Inn chicken pot pie is my absolute favorite.

It looks and tastes like it is prepared like they did in the late 1700’s.

There are hidden dumplings inside that are such a great surprise, along with perfect-sized bites of chicken and carrots.

It’s perfect every time.

MAYS LANDING DINER - MAYS LANDING, NEW JERSEY

Above, this is another “wow” example.

The Mays Landing Diner is a classic diner that makes great food.

Their chicken pot pie is fantastic.

Get our free mobile app

GORDON RAMSAY PUB & GRILL - CAESARS & HARRAH’S CASINOS - ATLANTIC CITY, NEW JERSEY

The above example, from The Gordon Ramsay Pub & Grill looks delicious and elegant … because it is.

JOE ITALIANO’S MAPLEWOOD INN - HAMMONTON, NEW JERSEY

A great Italian restaurant, that a loyal listener - reader of ours reports to us that they make a fabulous chicken pot pie.
TOWNE & COUNTRY - EGG HARBOR TOWNSHIP, NEW JERSEY

A great breakfast and lunch spot on Zion Road in Egg Harbor Township, New Jersey.

Above is their chicken pot pie that is packed with great flavor.

KENTUCKY FRIED CHICKEN - PLEASANTVILLE, NEW JERSEY

ST. GEORGE’S PUB - BRIGANTINE, NEW JERSEY

BONUS ENTRY - NANCY CONOVER - OWNER, PRESIDENT- THE SHORE AGENCY - ABSECON, NEW JERSEY

We had to include an Honorable Mention to Nancy’s wonderful chicken pot pie. It’s not available for consumers to purchase … however, it did win our highly competitive “Hurley in the Morning” Chicken Pot Pie contest.

This win officially placed Nancy’s chicken pot pie on The Gary’s Restaurant (Pleasantville, New Jersey) menu for one day.

Nancy’s unique interpretation calls for large homemade planks of pasta that makes you feel that you thrown back to the 1700’s.

Nancy shared with us that this amazing chicken pot pie is an Amish heritage dish which has been handed down through our family.

Nancy’s chicken pot pie is my all time favorite.

We enjoyed it so much at Gary’s Restaurant … it was so satisfying.

FROZEN VARIETY

This is me, (below) holding Don Hurley’s favorite previously prepared, frozen chicken pot pie.

As always, please let us know what we have missed … so that we can update our list and add more favorite chicken pot pie selections that are available in the Atlantic City, New Jersey area.